Ultimate Guide to Choosing a New vs. Refurbished Ice Resurfacer
Ultimate Guide to Choosing a New vs. Refurbished Ice Resurfacer
For ice rink operators and facility managers, choosing between a new and refurbished ice resurfacer can significantly impact both short- and long-term operations. New machines offer cutting-edge reliability, but come with a high price tag. Refurbished options may provide cost savings, but raise questions about performance and longevity. This guide outlines the key factors to consider—cost, reliability, serviceability, and total lifespan—so you can make a practical decision based on your rink’s specific needs.
What Is a Refurbished Ice Resurfacer?
A refurbished ice resurfacer is a pre-owned machine that has been restored to working condition through part replacement, mechanical servicing, and in many cases, cosmetic updates. At CTM Services, refurbishing typically includes:
- Engine and transmission servicing
- Hydraulic system inspection and repair
- Replacement of worn electrical components
- Optional repainting or bodywork
These machines are not “like new” in every case, but they are inspected and brought up to a reliable operational standard.
Cost Comparison: New vs Refurbished Units
| Equipment Type | Estimated Cost Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| New Olympia Model | $65,000 – $90,000 | Includes full OEM warranty |
| Refurbished Model | $30,000 – $50,000 | Price varies by condition, parts used |
While new machines offer longer warranty periods and newer technology, refurbished units can provide 30–50% savings upfront, freeing up budget for other arena priorities.
Reliability & Performance Considerations
New Machines:
- Predictable performance with fewer short-term repair needs
- Manufacturer-backed support
- Up-to-date features (e.g., hybrid or electric models)
Refurbished Machines:
- Performance depends on quality of refurbishing and parts used
- May lack newer features or software updates
- Regular maintenance more critical to extend lifespan
Properly serviced refurbished machines, especially from an authorized dealer, can serve reliably for many years.
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Factoring in repair costs, fuel efficiency, parts replacement, and downtime risk, here’s how the total cost of ownership can compare over 10 years:
- New Machine TCO (10 years): $90,000–$110,000
- Refurbished Machine TCO (10 years): $50,000–$80,000
This assumes regular maintenance. A refurbished unit may require more frequent minor repairs, but still delivers significant cost savings.
Who Should Consider Refurbished?
Refurbished ice resurfacers may be ideal for:
- Community rinks with tight budgets
- Facilities with a backup machine
- Rinks with skilled maintenance staff on hand
New machines are better suited for:
- Facilities with year-round heavy usage
- Venues needing the latest in emissions or hybrid tech
- Operators with low tolerance for downtime
FAQs
Is a refurbished ice resurfacer reliable enough for competitive hockey events?
A properly refurbished unit from an authorized dealer can absolutely meet high-performance needs—provided it is serviced regularly.
Can I get replacement parts for older refurbished models?
Yes, CTM Services stocks OEM parts for Olympia machines, including legacy models.
What’s the typical lifespan of a refurbished unit?
Expect 8–12 years of service, depending on usage and maintenance.
New vs. Refurbished Ice Resurfacer - Need Help? Call Us!
The decision between a new and refurbished ice resurfacer is less about which is better overall, and more about which is better for your specific operational needs. By weighing cost, performance expectations, and support availability, you can invest in the equipment that makes the most sense for your rink’s future.